Saturday, 14 November 2026

Daily Life Coaching Study Exercise – Day 10

 


Today's focus: Giving suggestions, offering guidance and respecting personal choice

Modules 1 and 2 · Coaching skills, autonomy and professional boundaries

Today we are looking at something that can sometimes be difficult for coaches and mentors: knowing when to ask questions, when to offer information and when to step back.

This builds on our previous studies of coaching versus mentoring, open-ended questions, professional boundaries and collaborative decision-making.

1. Should a coach give advice?

One of the important differences between coaching and other helping approaches is that coaching generally encourages people to discover their own answers.

A coach does not normally take control of the coachee's decisions.

For example, imagine someone says:

"I want to change careers, but I don't know where to start."

A coach might ask:

  • What interests you about changing careers?

  • What skills do you already have?

  • What opportunities have you considered?

  • What would you like to explore first?

These questions encourage independent thinking.

However, this does not mean a coach can never provide information or make suggestions.

Sometimes sharing relevant information or signposting someone to resources can be helpful.

The important thing is to avoid imposing your own decisions.

2. Asking permission before offering suggestions

A useful coaching skill is asking permission before sharing an idea.

For example:

Instead of saying:

"You should enrol on a training course."

The coach could say:

"Would you be interested in exploring some possible training opportunities?"

This gives the coachee a choice.

Other useful phrases include:

  • Would you like to hear a suggestion?

  • Would it be helpful if I shared some information?

  • Would you like to explore another possibility?

  • How does that suggestion sound to you?

  • What are your thoughts about that option?

The coachee can accept, reject or consider the suggestion.

Remember: Offering information should not remove someone's right to make their own decisions.

3. When personal experience can help

This is particularly relevant when comparing coaching and mentoring.

A mentor might share personal experience because they have relevant knowledge of a situation.

For example, a mentor who has experience of returning to education might explain some of the challenges they encountered.

However, they should not assume that another person will experience the same difficulties.

A coach might instead ask:

"What would you like to know about returning to education?"

Both approaches can be useful.

The important distinction is that personal experience should support the other person's development, not become the centre of the conversation.

4. Respecting autonomy

Autonomy means having the freedom and opportunity to make decisions about your own life.

In coaching, this includes respecting:

  • Personal goals.

  • Individual preferences.

  • Decisions about the future.

  • The right to disagree.

  • The right to change a goal.

  • The right to decline a suggestion.

Consider someone with a learning disability who wants to explore independent living.

A coach should not automatically decide what support they need.

They should explore what independence means to that individual.

One person might want help understanding tenancy agreements. Another might want to develop cooking skills. Someone else might already manage these activities independently.

The diagnosis does not determine the goal. The individual does.

5. When information or specialist advice is needed

Sometimes a coachee needs information that falls outside the coach's expertise.

For example:

Coachee's question

Appropriate response

What employment interests might suit me?

Explore interests and strengths through coaching.

What reasonable adjustments might I discuss with an employer?

Explore possible needs and signpost to appropriate employment guidance.

What medication should I take?

Explain that medication questions belong with an appropriate healthcare professional.

How do I challenge discrimination legally?

Signpost to an appropriate legal or advocacy service.

This demonstrates the importance of professional boundaries.

A coach can be supportive without pretending to have every answer.

6. Scenario-based exercise

Scenario: Returning to work

Sam wants to return to employment after spending several years away from work.

Sam has a disability and is concerned about how employers might respond to requests for reasonable adjustments.

The coach has personal experience of employment and immediately says:

"When I returned to work, I applied for several jobs. You should do the same."

Sam becomes quieter and says they are not sure that approach would work for them.

Your task:

Consider these four questions:

  1. Why might the coach's suggestion be unsuitable?

  2. How could the coach use their experience without assuming Sam's circumstances are the same?

  3. What open-ended question could help Sam explore employment options?

  4. How could the coach help Sam find appropriate information about reasonable adjustments without giving specialist legal advice?

7. Practical activity: Changing advice into coaching questions

Consider these three statements.

Rewrite each one as a more collaborative question.

  1. "You should go back to college."

  2. "You need to become more independent."

  3. "You ought to ask your employer for different working arrangements."

Think about how you can give the other person room to explain what they want.

8. Knowledge check

Try answering these questions before reading the answers.

Question 1. Why might a coach ask permission before offering a suggestion?

A. To make the coachee follow the coach's advice.

B. To respect the coachee's choice and involvement.

C. To avoid listening to the coachee.

Question 2. A coach has experienced a similar situation to their coachee. What should they remember?

A. Their experiences will be exactly the same.

B. They should make decisions for the coachee.

C. Their experience may be useful, but the coachee's circumstances and preferences may differ.

Question 3. What does autonomy mean?

A. Having opportunities to make decisions about your own life.

B. Always making decisions without any support.

C. Allowing professionals to decide what is best for you.

9. Answers and explanations

Suggested answers

Scenario exercise

  1. The coach assumes their own employment experience will be suitable for Sam. They have not explored Sam's individual circumstances or preferences.

  2. The coach could explain that they have had a similar experience but acknowledge that Sam's situation may be different. They could ask whether Sam would like to hear about it.

  3. "What would you like your return to employment to look like?"

  4. The coach could help Sam identify questions, explore possible adjustments and signpost to appropriate employment or disability advice.

Knowledge check

  1. B – Asking permission respects personal choice and encourages collaboration.

  2. C – Similar experiences do not mean identical needs or circumstances.

  3. A – Autonomy means having choice and control over decisions affecting your life.

10. Connection with your mentoring and advocacy experience

There is an important principle here that connects with your previous mentoring training and your disability awareness work.

Sometimes professionals believe they are helping because they have knowledge or experience.

However, what they consider helpful might not be what the person actually wants or needs.

For example, someone might want employment information, but not want somebody applying for jobs on their behalf.

Another person might want help exploring education without being pushed into a particular course.

This is where coaching, mentoring and advocacy share an important principle:

Support should strengthen someone's voice, not replace it.

Today's key learning point

Offer support, not control.

A good coach knows when to ask questions, when to offer information, when to seek permission and when to recognise that another professional may be better placed to help.

Study progress: Today's exercise revisits coaching versus mentoring, professional boundaries, autonomy, reasonable adjustments and collaborative communication. It develops the ability to support independent decision-making without imposing personal opinions.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Daily Life Coaching Study Exercise – Day 11

  Today's focus: Reviewing coaching progress, evaluating outcomes and measuring success Module 2 · Reviewing goals and coaching effectiv...