Today's focus: Reviewing coaching progress, evaluating outcomes and measuring success
Today we are looking at how a coach can recognise whether coaching is helping someone make progress.
We have already studied goal setting, SMART goals, GROW, accountability and continuous improvement.
Now we are bringing those subjects together.
An important question is:
How do we know whether coaching is making a positive difference to someone's life?
1. What does evaluating coaching mean?
Evaluating coaching means looking at what has happened during the coaching relationship and considering whether it has been useful.
This might include reviewing:
The goals originally agreed.
Actions the coachee has taken.
Skills and confidence developed.
Difficulties or barriers encountered.
Changes in the coachee's priorities.
Whether the coaching approach is working for them.
Evaluation should involve the coachee.
The coach should not decide independently whether someone has been successful.
For example, someone might originally want to find employment.
During coaching, they discover that they would prefer to gain a qualification first.
Although their original goal has changed, coaching may still have helped them understand their interests and make a more informed decision.
Changing a goal does not automatically mean coaching has failed.
2. Measuring progress without creating pressure
Some goals have clear ways of measuring progress.
For example:
Goal | Possible way to measure progress |
|---|---|
Complete a training course | Course completion or assessed work. |
Develop communication skills | Identify situations where communication feels more comfortable. |
Explore employment | Research opportunities and identify suitable options. |
Improve confidence | Recognise situations where the person feels more confident. |
Develop independence | Identify activities the person wants to manage more independently. |
However, not every achievement can be measured with numbers.
Confidence, self-awareness, motivation and personal development can be more difficult to measure.
A coach should not assume that completing more tasks always means making better progress.
3. Recognising small achievements
Sometimes a small achievement can represent considerable progress.
Imagine someone who wants to attend a local community group.
Their first steps might be:
Finding information about the group.
Contacting the organiser.
Asking about accessibility.
Finding out about transport.
Deciding whether they would like to attend.
Attending their first meeting.
The person might not attend immediately.
However, researching the group and contacting the organiser could still be meaningful progress.
The coachee should have an opportunity to recognise their own achievements.
A useful coaching question is:
"What are you pleased with since our last session?"
4. Feedback: Listening to the coachee
Feedback is important because it helps the coach understand how the coachee experiences the coaching relationship.
A coach might ask:
What have you found most useful?
Is there anything you would like to change?
Are our sessions meeting your expectations?
Is the pace comfortable for you?
Are the explanations and materials accessible?
What would make future sessions more useful?
The coach should be prepared to hear feedback they might not expect.
For example, a coachee might explain that the coach asks too many questions during one session.
Rather than becoming defensive, the coach could consider adjusting the pace.
This connects with our previous study of reflective practice and continuous improvement.
5. Accessibility and evaluating success
This is particularly important when supporting disabled people and people with mental health difficulties.
Imagine two people have the same goal of developing computer skills.
One person prefers written instructions.
Another prefers demonstrations and verbal explanations.
Both might achieve the same goal using different methods.
The coach should consider whether:
Information was accessible.
Reasonable adjustments were available.
The pace was appropriate.
The coachee felt included.
The person had enough opportunity to participate.
The agreed goals remained relevant.
Success should not be measured by comparing one disabled person with another.
It should be considered in relation to the individual's own goals, circumstances and progress.
6. Scenario-based exercise
Scenario: Reviewing a coaching relationship
Alex began coaching six weeks ago.
Their original goal was to improve confidence and explore returning to education.
During the coaching sessions, Alex has:
Identified two subjects of interest.
Researched local colleges.
Asked about learning support.
Developed a list of questions for a college visit.
However, Alex has not yet applied for a course.
The coach is disappointed because the original target was to submit an application within six weeks.
Your task:
Consider these four questions.
Has Alex made progress, even though the application has not been submitted?
Why should the coach review the original deadline with Alex?
What questions could the coach ask to understand Alex's experience of coaching?
How could the coach evaluate whether the coaching sessions have been accessible and useful?
7. Practical activity: Your evaluation exercise
Imagine you are coaching someone who wants to develop their confidence.
Write down:
One question to help them recognise their achievements.
One question to identify difficulties.
One question to obtain feedback about the coaching sessions.
One way to recognise progress without comparing them with other people.
Keep the questions open-ended and supportive.
8. Knowledge check
Try answering these three questions before looking at the answers.
Question 1. What is the main purpose of evaluating coaching?
A. To prove that the coach is always successful.
B. To review progress, usefulness and possible improvements.
C. To make sure every original goal is completed.
Question 2. A coachee changes their original goal after discovering a new interest. What should the coach do?
A. Insist that the original goal must remain unchanged.
B. Treat the change as a failure.
C. Explore the new goal and agree on an appropriate way forward.
Question 3. Why is individual progress important when evaluating coaching?
A. Because everyone should achieve the same results.
B. Because progress should reflect the individual's goals, circumstances and needs.
C. Because adjustments should never be considered.
9. Answers and explanations
Suggested answers
Scenario exercise
Yes. Alex has researched courses, identified interests and explored learning support. These are meaningful steps towards the goal.
Circumstances and priorities may have changed. The coach should discuss whether the deadline remains appropriate.
The coach could ask what Alex has found useful, what has been difficult and what they would like to change.
The coach could ask whether information was understandable, whether the pace was suitable and whether any additional adjustments would help.
Knowledge check
B – Evaluation helps understand whether coaching is useful and what could improve.
C – Coaching should remain responsive to the coachee's changing priorities.
B – Individual progress is more meaningful than comparing people with different circumstances.
10. Connection with your mentoring and disability awareness work
There is an important connection between today's topic and your previous experience in mentoring and disability awareness training.
When evaluating a person's progress, professionals sometimes concentrate too much on what someone has not achieved.
For example, someone might not have found employment yet.
However, they may have developed new skills, improved their confidence, explored training or identified workplace adjustments they need.
These achievements should not be dismissed.
Equally, we should not assume that every person wants employment, education or greater independence in the same way.
The individual's own priorities matter.
I would include this principle in Always Learn About Disability + Never Judge Disability:
Measure progress by understanding the individual, recognising their achievements and considering the barriers they face. Do not judge someone solely by what they have or have not completed.
Today's key learning point
Progress is more than completing a target.
Good coaching evaluation recognises achievements, listens to feedback, considers accessibility and allows goals to change when circumstances or priorities change.
Study progress: Today's exercise brings together collaborative goal setting, accountability, feedback, reflective practice, accessibility and continuous improvement. It develops the ability to review coaching effectiveness without imposing a single definition of success.
No comments:
Post a Comment